Chewy Sea Salt Caramels infused with ROSEMARY! Because salted caramels are great, but herb-infused caramels are better. Finish with sea salt to create the ultimate sea salt caramel.

sea salt caramels arranges on a piece of brown parchment paper

Tips for Making Homemade Caramels

Use a candy thermometer. Without a candy thermometer, making these dark chocolate sea salt caramels at home will be more than challenging.

Be prepared. Most of the action happens within 30 seconds when making caramel. It’s important to move fast and efficiently. The temperature of sugar can rise rapidly; just a few extra seconds over heat, or a delay in adding butter can drastically change the product.

Use a combination of sugars. It’s important to use a combination of sugar types when making caramel (sucrose, fructose, glucose). More type of sugar = variety of molecule shapes.

When one type of sugar is used, the molecules nestle together during cooling, creating gritty, crumbly crystals. Using a combination of sugars means the sugar molecules won’t crystalize as easily, resulting in a caramel that’s silky and smooth.

Use heavy whipping cream. Avoid using cream that's simply labeled "whipping cream" as it might have a lower percentage of fat. For this recipe, your cream should have a minimum of 36% fat content.

Watch How to Make Sea Salt Caramels:

Prevent crystallization

When making homemade caramel, it's important to avoid crystallization. Crystallization is the opposite of everything we love about soft, chewy caramels. When sugar crystalizes it creates a grainy texture in the finished product.

When adding the granulated sugar to the pan, before you even begin cooking, it's important to avoid getting any granules on the sides of the pans. To avoid this, slowly pour the sugar in the center of the pan.

During the first stage of cooking, if you see any crystallization start to form on the sides of the pan, carefully brush the sides of the pan with some water using a pastry brush.

close up of a sea salt caramel on a piece of parchment paper

Use a Thermometer

First and foremost, you WILL need a candy thermometer or instant-read thermometer for these sea salt caramels. Unless you can make caramels purely off of intuition (in that case you probably don't need to be here), then you need a thermometer.

Temperature is absolutely key to achieving successful caramels. For candy making, I like to use a candy thermometer. They have a handy clip that allows you to clip the thermometer right to the side of the pan (nice for avoiding a steam-induced burn). Candy thermometers also usually feature a guard to keep the probe of the thermometer from touching the bottom of the pan.

If your candy thermometer doesn't have a guard, just be sure to not let the probe touch the bottom of the pan.

How to calibrate a thermometer: Test your thermometer by taking the temperature of boiling water—it should read 212°F. Adjust the recipe temperature up or down based on your test.

Making Caramel is All About Temperature

This sea salt caramel recipe has two important temperatures to keep in mind.

As a quick reference, the sugar syrup will first be cooked to 320ºF (160ºC) to 325ºF (163ºC).

Then, secondly, the caramel mixture will be cooked to 240°F (115ºC) to 245ºF (118ºC).

This two-step process is important for achieving deep flavor and adequate texture. The first temperature, 320ºF (160ºC), cooks the sugar syrup past hard-crack stage (think hard sugar candies like brittles and poured suckers), and into the caramel stage.

At this stage, nearly all of the moisture from the mixture has evaporated out and the sugar is now browning and becoming caramel. True caramel, kept in this original state, is used to make brittles, pralines, and nougatine.

The second step of this process is adding fat and moisture to the caramel mixture, and cooking it to a much lower temperature, 240°F (115ºC), to create a soft and chewy caramel.

If you like softer caramels, cook the caramel in the second stage to 240°F (115ºC).

If you're like me and prefer a chewier caramel, cook the caramel in the second stage to 245ºF (118ºC).

Swirling vs Stirring

Homemade caramel may seem finicky, but I'm here to tell you, if you follow the recipe you'll find that homemade caramel is actually quite simple. One thing to keep in mind—don't stir unless the recipe tells you to stir!

It might not seem like a big deal—but when it comes to caramel it is! During the first stage of cooking there's no need to stir. Let the mixture bubble away, uninterrupted, until the sides of the pan start to turn amber brown. Once browning starts to occur, even the slightest, you can give the pan a little swirl.

You can stir the mixture in the second stage of cooking, when the cream and butter mixture has been added.

How to Clean the Sticky Pan

Cleaning hardened caramel out of a pan can be a big pain in the rear. For easier clean up, fill the saucepan with water and bring to a boil. Watch the caramel melt away! Add the candy thermometer, rubber spatula and/or wooden spoon to the pot if they also have stuck on caramel.

Variations on this sea salt caramel recipe:

Instead of infusing the cream with rosemary, add the seeds of one vanilla bean.
Swap the rosemary sprig for a few peels of orange zest.
Drizzle each caramel with dark chocolate.